| Pos. |
First Team |
|
Second Team |
| QB |
Kevin Burke, Jr., Mount
Union |
|
Spencer Stanek, Sr., North Central |
| RB |
Domonique Hayden, Jr., Thomas More |
|
Octavias McKoy, Sr., Western Connecticut |
| RB |
Cartel Brooks, Jr.,
Heidelberg |
|
Cole Myhra, Sr., UW-Oshkosh |
| WR |
Kyle Linville, Sr., Franklin |
|
Holton Walker, Jr., Hampden-Sydney |
| WR |
Anthony Davis, Jr., Widener |
|
Alex Baroffio, Sr., Washington and Jefferson |
| TE |
Adam Carl, Sr., Augsburg |
|
Jared Prugar, Sr., Ithaca |
| T |
Steven Schultz, Sr., Linfield |
|
Jeff Schmidt, Sr., Bethel |
| G |
Nathan Yelton, Sr., Coe |
|
Chuck North, Sr., Hardin-Simmons |
| C |
Ben Cranston, Sr., Johns Hopkins |
|
Hunter Feibel, Sr., Louisiana College |
| G |
James Thomas, Sr., St. John Fisher |
|
Brendan Kozub, Sr., Lebanon Valley |
| T |
Quentin Rembert, Sr.,
Heidelberg |
|
Armand Jenifer, Sr. Johns Hopkins |
| |
|
|
|
| Defense |
|
|
|
| DE |
Cody Buresh, Jr., Wabash |
|
Korey Steward, Sr., Mary Hardin-Baylor |
| DT |
Tyler Steele, Sr., Linfield |
|
Matt Fechko, Sr., Mount
Union |
| DT |
Silvio Diaz, Sr. Mary Hardin-Baylor |
|
Ben Poirer, Jr.,
Heidelberg |
| DE |
Danny Samson, Sr., Central |
|
Alex Tripp, Sr., North Central |
| LB |
Erik Westerberg, Sr., Augustana |
|
Frank Gaffney, Jr., Lebanon Valley |
| LB |
Dom Forrest, Sr., Linfield |
|
Andre Carter, Sr., LaGrange |
| LB |
Cole Klotz, Sr., UW-Whitewater |
|
Seth Mathis, Sr., Bethel |
| CB |
Andre Carter, Sr., Salisbury |
|
Randy Greenwood, Sr., John
Carroll |
| S |
Shane Dierking, Sr., North Central |
|
Drew Peterson, Sr., Albright |
| S |
Tanner Troutman, Jr., Lycoming |
|
Austin Blashka, Sr., UW-Oshkosh |
| CB |
Brodrick Crain, Sr., Mary Hardin-Baylor |
|
C.J. Conway, Jr., Montclair State |
| |
|
|
|
| Specialists |
|
|
|
| K |
Andrew Franks, Jr., RPI |
|
Dylan Rushe, Sr. Endicott |
| P |
Kyle Hamby, Jr., Salisbury |
|
Matt Harmon, Sr., Baldwin
Wallace |
| RET |
Hakeem Bourne-McFarlane, Sr., Augsburg |
|
Jessie Ramos, So., Hardin-Simmons |
| ST |
|
|
Gabriel Smith, Fr., Hobart |
| |
|
|
|
|
Pos.
|
Third Team |
Pos. |
Honorable Mention |
| QB |
John Kelly, Sr., UW-Platteville |
QB |
Nash Nance, Jr., Hampden-Sydney |
| RB |
Steven Webb, Sr. Hobart |
RB |
Will McGhee, Sr., Randolph-Macon |
| RB |
Melikke Van Alstyne, Sr., Framingham St. |
RB |
Jeffrey Dubose, Sr., Gustavus Adolphus |
| WR |
Mitch Hallstrom, Sr., Bethel |
WR |
Jake Kumerow, Jr., UW-Whitewater |
| WR |
Tyler Rutenbeck, Jr., Dubuque |
WR |
John Babin, Jr., Cortland State |
| TE |
Michael Long, Jr., Muhlenberg |
WR |
Luc Meacham, Jr., Mount
Union |
| T |
Aaron Coeling, Sr., Wittenberg |
T |
Jace Werkheiser, Sr., North Central |
| G |
Jason Cook, Sr., Baldwin
Wallace |
G |
Lucas Skibba, Jr., UW-Whitewater |
| C |
Michael Green, Sr., Hobart |
C |
Paul Santi, Sr., UW-Eau Claire |
| G |
Josh Holt, St., Mary Hardin-Baylor |
G |
Rance Hightower, Jr., Maryville |
| T |
Ryan DiFlavio, Sr., Alfred |
T |
Connor Hollenbeck, Sr., Washington and Lee |
| |
|
|
|
| Defense |
|
|
|
| DE |
Chris Alvarez, Jr., Rowan |
|
Tyre Coleman, Jr., Hobart |
| DT |
Hayden Stanton, So., Salve Regina |
|
Dwight Hentz, Sr., Lycoming |
| DT |
Mitch Montgomery, Sr., Coe |
|
Brandon Felus, Sr., Juniata |
| DE |
Nate Adams, Jr., Concordia-Moorhead |
|
Adham Talaat, Sr., Gallaudet |
| LB |
Sosthene Kapepula, Jr., Wesley |
|
Devin Worthington, Sr., Hobart |
| LB |
Nick Slezak, Sr., North Central |
|
Nick Bricker, Sr., TCNJ |
| LB |
Tyler Ikwild, Sr., Hampden-Sydney |
|
Nate Scola, Sr., Wabash |
| CB |
Marcus McLin, Jr., UW-Whitewater |
|
Rob Austin, Jr., UW-Platteville |
| S |
Satiir Stevenson, Jr., Guilford |
|
Jared Morris, Sr., Wesley |
| S |
Cody Jones, Sr., Mary Hardin-Baylor |
|
Alec French, Sr., St. Scholastica |
| CB |
Tony Sierra, Sr., Defiance |
|
Kenyon O'Brien, Sr., Concordia-Moorhead |
| |
|
|
|
| Specialists |
|
|
|
| K |
Daniel Sobolewski, So., Albright |
|
Eric Kindler, Sr., UW-Whitewater |
| P |
Tracy Murden, Sr., Randolph-Macon |
|
Cameron Sobleski, Sr., Wabash |
| RET |
Jordan Zackery, Jr., Franklin and Marshall |
|
Justin Howard, Jr., UW-Whitewater |
| ST |
Dan Egan, Jr., St. Norbert |
|
Shawn Bowman, Jr., Wooster |