| Pos. |
First
Team |
Second
Team |
| Offense |
|
| QB |
Kevin Burke, Sr., Mount
Union |
Nash Nance, Sr., Hampden-Sydney |
| RB |
Cartel Brooks, Sr.,
Heidelberg |
Sean Dunning, Sr., Millikin |
| RB |
Domonique Hayden, Sr., Thomas More |
Mike Barthelemy, Sr., Millsaps |
| WR |
Jake Kumerow, Sr., UW-Whitewater |
Holton Walker, Sr., Hampden-Sydney |
| WR |
Anthony Davis, Sr., Widener |
John Babin, Sr., Cortland State |
| TE |
Michael Long, Sr., Muhlenberg |
Joe Sommers, Jr., UW-Oshkosh |
| T |
Stephen Schultz, Sr., Linfield |
Dalton Stephens, Sr., Maryville |
| G |
Lucas Skibba, Sr., UW-Whitewater |
Devin Filliben, Jr., Wesley |
| C |
Spencer Clark, Sr., Wheaton (Ill.) |
Alex Damschroder, Jr.
Heidelberg |
| G |
Tevon Stephens-Brown, Sr., Pac.
Lutheran |
Austin Carlton, Jr., Franklin |
| T |
Chris Brinkmeier, Sr., Wartburg
|
Ali Marpet, Sr., Hobart |
| Defense |
|
| DE |
Cody Buresh, Sr., Wabash |
Brynnan Hyland, Sr., Linfield |
| DT |
Ben Poirer, Sr.,
Heidelberg |
Hayden Stanton, Jr., Salve Regina |
| DT |
Shaun Copening, Sr., Christopher
Newport |
Jake Stillwell, Jr., Hanover |
| DE |
Tyre Coleman, Sr., Hobart |
Teidrick Smith, So., Mary
Hardin-Baylor |
| LB |
Frank Gaffney, Sr., Lebanon Valley |
Luke Bakkum, Sr., UW-Stout |
| LB |
Sosthene Kapepula, Sr., Wesley |
Jacob Zilbar, Sr., UW-Platteville |
| LB |
Sean Preish, Sr., St. John Fisher
|
Jack Nelson, Sr., Willamette |
| CB |
Brady Grayvold, Sr., UW-Whitewater |
Ryan Rice, Sr., Johns Hopkins |
| S |
Satiir Stevenson, Sr., Guilford |
Alex Kocheff, Jr., Mount
Union |
| S |
Tanner Troutman, Sr., Lycoming |
Matt Mehlhorn, Jr., Bethel |
| CB |
C.J. Conway, Sr., Montclair State |
Rob Austin, Sr., UW-Platteville |
| Special
teams |
|
| K |
Andrew Franks, Sr., RPI |
Daniel Sobolewski, Jr., Albright |
| P |
Kyle Hamby, Sr., Salisbury |
Tyler Hunt, Jr., Guilford |
| RET |
Jessie Ramos, Jr., Hardin-Simmons |
Sam Carney, Sr., Ithaca |