| 2016 Mideast-ABCA/Rawlings All-Region Teams |
| NCAA Div. III Mideast All-Region First Team |
| Pos. |
Player |
Cl. |
School |
State |
| C |
Aaron Caputo |
Sr. |
Ohio Wesleyan |
OH |
| 1B |
Jamie Lackner |
Jr. |
Wooster |
OH |
| 2B |
Ben Laumann |
So. |
Thomas More |
KY |
| 3B |
Joe Killian |
Sr. |
Allegheny |
PA |
| SS |
Ryan Dorow |
Jr. |
Adrian |
MI |
| OF |
Tyler Kent |
Sr. |
Otterbein |
OH |
| OF |
Luis Navedo |
Jr. |
La Roche |
PA |
| OF |
Ryan Konkle |
Sr. |
Hope |
MI |
| DH |
Benjamin Legath |
Jr. |
Mount Aloysius |
PA |
| UT |
Mark Zimmerman |
Sr. |
Baldwin Wallace |
OH |
| UT |
Matt Elko |
Sr. |
Thiel |
PA |
| P |
Christian Herstine |
Sr. |
Marietta |
OH |
| P |
Tanner Wilt |
Sr. |
La Roche |
PA |
| P |
Ryan Orr |
So. |
Kalamazoo |
MI |
| P |
Tommy Parsons |
So. |
Adrian |
MI |
| |
| NCAA Div. III Mideast All-Region Second Team |
| Pos. |
Player |
Cl. |
School |
State |
| C |
James Weber |
Sr. |
Mount Union |
OH |
| C |
Dan Koller |
Sr. |
Thiel |
PA |
| 1B |
Matt Waugaman |
Jr. |
Grove City |
PA |
| 1B |
Donovan Pogue |
Sr. |
Thomas More |
KY |
| 1B |
Ben Herstine |
Jr. |
La Roche |
PA |
| 2B |
Scott Sada |
Fr. |
Penn State Behrend |
PA |
| 2B |
Taylor Hutchison |
Sr. |
Otterbein |
OH |
| 3B |
Logan Bastin |
Jr. |
Capital |
OH |
| SS |
Michael Wielansky |
Fr. |
Wooster |
OH |
| OF |
Michael Fischbach |
Sr. |
Albion |
MI |
| OF |
Trey Simpson |
Sr. |
Transylvania |
KY |
| OF |
Nick Vento |
Jr. |
Washington & Jefferson |
PA |
| OF |
Ben Kenning |
Jr. |
Thomas More |
KY |
| P |
Alec McNally |
Sr. |
Rose-Hulman |
IN |
| P |
Chase Boyer |
Jr. |
Allegheny |
PA |
| P |
Brian Resnik |
Sr. |
Waynesburg |
PA |
| P |
Regis Sauer |
So. |
La Roche |
PA |
| P |
Michael Houdek |
Jr. |
Wooster |
OH |
| P |
Robert Kemer |
Jr. |
Otterbein |
OH |
| P |
Evan Lovick |
So. |
Baldwin Wallace |
OH |
| |
| NCAA Div. III Mideast All-Region Third Team |
| Pos. |
Player |
Cl. |
School |
State |
| C |
Andy Fritz |
Jr. |
Grove City |
PA |
| 1B |
Colton Wolfe |
Jr. |
Calvin |
MI |
| 2B |
Caleb Kissel |
Sr. |
Rose-Hulman |
IN |
| 2B |
David Crowley |
Sr. |
John Carroll |
OH |
| 3B |
David Lemley |
Jr. |
La Roche |
PA |
| OF |
Jim Shomberg |
So. |
Penn State Altoona |
PA |
| OF |
Ian Mikowski |
Jr. |
Adrian |
MI |
| OF |
Derek Hug |
Sr. |
Heidelberg |
OH |
| OF |
Connor Bowie |
Sr. |
Mount Aloysius |
PA |
| OF |
Casey Metzger |
Jr. |
Thomas More |
KY |
| OF |
Christian Leitenberger |
Sr. |
Muskingum |
OH |
| P |
David Stover |
So. |
Marietta |
OH |
| P |
Jake Shields |
Jr. |
Case Western Reserve |
OH |
| P |
Riley Groves |
Jr. |
Washington & Jefferson |
PA |
| P |
Riley Futterknecht |
Jr. |
DePauw |
IN |
| |
| **Mideast Region Position Player of the Year: Mark Zimmerman, Baldwin Wallace |
| **Mideast Region Pitcher of the Year: Christian Herstine, Marietta |