| Previous Champions |
Previous Medalists |
Previous Coaches of the Year |
| 2025 - John Carroll |
2025 - Michael Keefe (John Carroll) |
2025 - Tom Arison (Marietta) |
| 2024 - Ottebein |
2024 - Ian Johnston (Otterbein) |
2024 - Brian Booher (Otterbein) |
| 2023 - Otterbein |
2023 - Angelo Donato (Capital) |
2023 - Brian Booher (Otterbein) |
| 2022 - John Carroll |
2022 - Ian Smith (MTU), John Roder (JCU) |
2022 - Mike Moran (John Carroll) |
| 2021 - Otterbein |
2021 - Coury Rogers (Otterbein) |
2021 - Brian Booher (Otterbein) |
| 2020 - (COVID-19) |
2020 - (COVID-19) |
2020 - (COVID-19) |
| 2019 - Otterbein |
2019 - Sam Marty (Otterbein) |
2019 - Wayne Schneider (Baldwin Wallace) |
| 2018 - Otterbein |
2018 - John Schnur (John Carroll) |
2018 - Brian Booher (Otterbein) |
| 2017 - Otterbein |
2017 - Scott Schroeder (Baldwin Wallace) |
2017 - Brian Booher (Otterbein) |
| 2016 - Otterbein |
2016 - David Monaco (Otterbein) |
2016 - Brian Booher (Otterbein) |
| 2015 - Otterbein |
2015 - Nick Popely (Mount Union) |
2015 - Brian Booher (Otterbein) |
| 2014 - Baldwin Wallace |
2014 - Adam Sanders (Baldwin Wallace) |
2014 - Tom Heil (Baldwin Wallace) |
| 2013 - Otterbein |
2013 - Alex DiPalma (John Carroll) |
2013 - Matt Cooperrider (OTT), Dan MacDuffie (MTU) |
| 2012 - Otterbein |
2012 - Ben Adams (Otterbein) |
2012 - Matt Cooperrider (Otterbein) |
| 2011 - Mount Union |
2011 - Scott Miller (Mount Union) |
2011 - Dan MacDuffie (Mount Union) |
| 2010 - Otterbein |
2010 - Cody MacLean (Otterbein) |
2010 - Mark Paluszak (Otterbein) |
| 2009 - Otterbein |
2009 - Zack Koinis (Heidelberg) |
2009 - Nathanael Petry (Otterbein) |
| 2008 - Mount Union |
2008 - Zack Koinis (Heidelberg) |
2008 - Dan MacDuffie (Mount Union) |
| 2007 - Mount Union |
2007 - Dan Fisher (Muskingum) |
2007 - Greg Kline (Capital) |
| 2006 - Otterbein |
2006 - Zach Sebert (Otterbein) |
2006 - Matt Smith (Otterbein) |
| 2005 - Otterbein |
2005 - Andy Miller (Otterbein) |
2005 - Matt Smith (Otterbein) |
| 2004 - Otterbein |
2004 - Andy Miller (Otterbein) |
2004 - Matt Smith (Otterbein) |
| 2003 - Otterbein |
2003 - Steve Weir (Baldwin Wallace) |
2003 - Dave Kirby (Muskingum) |
| 2002 - Otterbein |
2002 - Ryan Dorff (Otterbein) |
2002 - Dave McLaughlin (Otterbein) |
| 2001 - Otterbein |
2001 - Brett Williams (Otterbein) |
2001 - Ed DiGenova (Muskingum) |
| 2000 - Otterbein |
2000 - B.J. Pitzen (Otterbein) |
2000 - Dave McLaughlin (Otterbein) |