(as voted by the league coaches)
Coaching Staff of the Year: Capital
Capital’s coaching staff is led by 12th-year head coach Matt Ogden, who is assisted by Megan Wharton-Dombrowski, Avery Hart, Nikki Cox, Mario Suarez, and Geovanny Salinas. The Comets were selected to win the 2026 OAC title in preseason voting and delivered on that pick, going 7-1 in OAC play.
Scholar-Athlete of the Year: Elise Buckerfield, Capital
Capital sophomore Elise Buckerfield is a 4.00 Biology (Pre-Med) major. This season, she earned OAC Defensive Player of the Week honors and helped anchor a defense that recorded seven shutouts. In addition to her excellent performance in the classroom and on the field, Buckerfield is an Athletics Game Management student worker and regularly volunteers with her team and the department at organizations throughout central Ohio.
Freshman of the Year: Blake Sakach, Ohio Northern + Megan Foulke, Capital
Capital freshman defender Megan Foulke was a fixture in the lineup for the Comets, starting all 17 games. She produced four goals and an assist for nine points and helped anchor a defense that allowed just 0.76 goals per game and recorded seven shutouts.
Ohio Northern freshman goalkeeper Blake Sakach was a steady presence in net for the Polar Bears, allowing only eight goals this season and recording seven clean sheets.
Midfielder of the Year: Kasey Duke, Capital
Capital junior midfielder Kasey Duke was a steady presence in the middle of the field for the Comets this season. She scored four goals and helped Capital post a 7-1 record in the OAC to clinch a share of the regular-season title.
Forward of the Year: Brianna Braatz, Heidelberg
Heidelberg junior Brianna Braatz led the OAC in goals with 13 and in points per game at 1.81. Her 29 points ranked second in the league, and she earned All-OAC First Team honors for the second straight year.
Goalkeeper of the Year: Blake Sakach, Ohio Northern
Ohio Northern freshman Blake Sakach helped anchor the Polar Bears’ defense as they went 7-1 in the OAC and clinched a share of the regular-season title. She recorded seven clean sheets and allowed only eight goals.
Defender of the Year: Elise Buckerfield, Capital
Capital sophomore Elise Buckerfield earned OAC Defensive Player of the Week honors and helped anchor a Comets defense that recorded seven shutouts. She was also named Scholar-Athlete of the Year and earned All-OAC First Team honors.
First Team
| Position |
Name |
School |
Class |
| Goalkeeper |
Blake Sakach |
Ohio Northern |
Fr. |
| Defender |
Elise Buckerfield # |
Capital |
So. |
| Defender |
Kelayna Patrick |
Otterbein |
Fr. |
| Defender |
Ella James # |
Baldwin Wallace |
Sr. |
| Midfielder |
Kasey Duke |
Capital |
Jr. |
| Midfielder |
Sarah Beachy |
Ohio Northern |
So. |
| Midfielder |
Elise Papp |
Baldwin Wallace |
Jr. |
| Forward |
Brianna Braatz # |
Heidelberg |
Jr.* |
| Forward |
Payton Childers |
Capital |
Jr. |
| Forward |
Kalyn Rich # |
Baldwin Wallace |
Sr. |
| Midfielder |
Jordan Snyder $ |
Wilmington |
Sr. |
| Defender |
Tati Grigoryan # |
Marietta |
Sr. |
Second Team
| Position |
Name |
School |
Class |
| Goalkeeper |
Francesca Agliolo # |
Marietta |
Sr.* |
| Defender |
Megan Foulke |
Capital |
Fr. |
| Defender |
Caroline Hennegan $ |
Ohio Northern |
Sr.* |
| Defender |
Kendra Kovacs |
Capital |
Jr. |
| Defender |
Maggie Springer |
Capital |
Fr. |
| Midfielder |
Ella Dinwiddie ! |
Mount Union |
Sr. |
| Midfielder |
Mia Fourtounis ! |
Baldwin Wallace |
Sr. |
| Midfielder |
Alexis Pickerel |
Otterbein |
Jr. |
| Forward |
Jaylyn Thornton |
Marietta |
— |
| Forward |
Olivia Brooks |
Otterbein |
Jr. |
| Forward |
Juli Sprague $ |
Capital |
So. |
| Forward |
Adilyn Doriot |
Ohio Northern |
Fr. |
| Goalkeeper |
Isabella Neal |
Otterbein |
Sr. |
Third Team
| Position |
Name |
School |
Class |
| Goalkeeper |
Mackenzie Butcher |
Baldwin Wallace |
Fr. |
| Defender |
Lindsey Bauer $ |
Wilmington |
Jr. |
| Goalkeeper |
Leanne Williams |
Mount Union |
Jr. |
| Forward |
Brooklyn Herbert |
Capital |
So. |
| Forward |
Rachel Chenos ! |
Mount Union |
Jr. |
| Midfielder |
Myah Byers $ |
Marietta |
Sr.* |
| Midfielder |
Kristiane Kleppe |
Capital |
So. |
| Midfielder |
Sarah Kelly |
Capital |
So. |
| Forward |
Ayva Moore $ |
Ohio Northern |
So. |
| Defender |
Keaton Aspacher ! |
Otterbein |
Jr. |
Key: # 2025 First Team … $ 2025 Second Team … ! 2025 Third Team